Search

Cat Tracks Online Newsletter

EGSC Professor Lee Cheek Edits Book on the Great “Onslow” Debate

EGSC Professor Lee Cheek Edits Book on the Great “Onslow” Debate

EGSC Professor Lee Cheek Edits Book on the Great “Onslow” Debate


EGSC Professor Lee Cheek Edits Book on the Great “Onslow” Debate

An East Georgia State College Professor, Dr. Lee Cheek, has just published a book on a “lost” debate in American politics between President John Quincy Adams and his political supporters, and Vice-President John C. Calhoun.  The book, Patrick Henry-Onslow Debate: Liberty and Republicanism in American Political Thought, was published by Lexington Books, an internationally-respected publisher.  Dr. Cheek co-edited the volume, which gathers documents on one of the most momentous political debates about the meaning of republican government in the decades before the Civil War.

The debate followed the disputed Election of 1824. After an indecisive electoral college vote, the House of Representatives selected John Quincy Adams as president over the more popular war hero, Andrew Jackson. As a result, John C. Calhoun ended up serving as vice-president under Adams. Neither man was comfortable in this situation as they were political rivals who held philosophically divergent views of American constitutional governance. The emerging personal and philosophical dispute between President Adams and Vice-President Calhoun eventually prompted the two men (and Adams’s political supporters) to take up their pens, using the pseudonyms “Patrick Henry” and “Onslow,” in a public debate over the nature of power and liberty in a constitutional republic.
“The great debate,” notes Kevin Gutzman of Western Connecticut State University, “arrayed Calhoun’s Jeffersonian republican vision of constitutionally restrained power and local autonomy against Adams’s neo-Federalist republican vision which called for the positive use of inherent power—a view that would become increasingly compelling to future generations of Americans.” The debate between Vice President John C. Calhoun (‘Onslow’) and President John Quincy Adams or his ally (‘Patrick Henry’) captures the clash between Jeffersonian and Hamiltonian views at a pivotal moment in American history.
While the debate has not received the scholarly attention it deserves, the publication of this new book will reawaken interest in the vital dialogue. In an early review of the book, Dr. Robert Paquette of Hamilton College suggests: “The debate between ‘Patrick Henry’ and ‘Onslow,’ said Paquette, “fought out in the pages of Washington newspapers in 1826, speaks to the idea of competing visions, present at the founding of the United States, of republican government. The editors of this timely volume return us to a lost world in which a seemingly small incident in the Senate could spark within the highest levels of government a deep and candid public analysis of the dialectic of liberty and power and its relation to the problem of limited government. Cheek and company deserve applause for this illuminating act of recovery.”
Dr. Cheek is Chair of the Social Sciences and Professor of Political Science at East Georgia State College, in Swainsboro, Georgia. His many publications include Calhoun and Popular Rule (2001).
 

Originally Posted: December 10, 2013 by Jerry Hooks
Last Edited: February 24, 2014 by Jerry Hooks